Back to Blog
Form I-9
Rehires
Staffing Compliance
USCIS

I-9 Rehire Rules: When You Can Reuse a Temp's Form I-9

Michael··11 min read·Updated
I-9 Rehire Rules: When You Can Reuse a Temp's Form I-9

I-9 rehire rules for staffing firms: when Supplement B covers a returning temp, when you need a new Form I-9, reverification and retention.

Last reviewed: 12 October 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Under the I-9 rehire rules, you may use Supplement B instead of a new form if you rehire someone within three years. The three years run from the date their previous Form I-9 was completed. After three years, the worker must complete a new Form I-9. Either way, if their employment authorization has expired, you must reverify it before they work.

In short:

  • Rehired within three years of the original Form I-9: complete a Supplement B block, or a new Form I-9 if you prefer.
  • Rehired three years or more after the original Form I-9: a new Form I-9 is required.
  • If the employee's work authorization has expired, reverify it in Supplement B. Never reverify U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals, or because a Green Card expired.
  • A temp who stays employed by your firm between assignments is not being rehired.
  • Keep the form for three years from the original Form I-9 or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.

What are the I-9 rehire rules?

The rule is a three-year window that runs from the date the previous Form I-9 was completed, not from the date the employee left.

The USCIS Handbook for Employers (M-274), section 6.2, sets out two paths:

  • Rehired within three years of the date you completed their previous Form I-9: you may complete a block in Supplement B, Reverification and Rehire, or complete a new Form I-9 instead.
  • Rehired three years or more after you originally completed their Form I-9: the employee must complete a new Form I-9.

The regulation behind this is 8 CFR 274a.2(c). It lets you rely on the earlier form if it is for the same person and they are still eligible to work. You must update it with the rehire date.

What is Supplement B?

Supplement B is the reverification and rehire page of the current Form I-9, which used to be Section 3.

USCIS explains it on its I-9 Central page, Completing Supplement B, Reverification and Rehires. You attach each completed block to the employee's existing Form I-9.

When can you use Supplement B for a rehired temp?

You can use Supplement B when the rehire date falls within three years of the date the original Form I-9 was completed.

What to enter in the Supplement B block

M-274 section 6.2 says that for an employee who is still authorized to work, you:

  1. Enter the employee's full name as it appears on the original Form I-9.
  2. Enter any new name in the New Name fields, if their name has changed.
  3. Enter the date of rehire.
  4. Sign and date the block, and print your name.

No new documents are needed for an employee who is still authorized to work. That includes U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals and lawful permanent residents with a Form I-551.

What if the old Form I-9 is an outdated edition?

If the previous Form I-9 is an earlier version, M-274 says the new Supplement B block must go on the current version. Keep that block with the previous Form I-9. Check uscis.gov/i-9 for the edition currently accepted.

What if you already used Supplement B for an earlier rehire?

You can add another Supplement B block for a later rehire, as long as it still falls within three years of the original Form I-9. Once that window has passed, the employee needs a new Form I-9.

When is a new Form I-9 required for a rehire?

A new Form I-9 is required when the rehire date is three years or more after the date the original Form I-9 was completed.

You can also choose a new Form I-9 for a rehire inside the three-year window. This can make sense when the old form is hard to find, incomplete or on an old edition.

Here is a quick decision table for a returning temp.

SituationWhat to do
Rehired within 3 years, still authorized to workSupplement B block with the rehire date, or a new Form I-9
Rehired within 3 years, work authorization expiredSupplement B block with rehire date and reverification, or a new Form I-9
Rehired 3 years or more after the original Form I-9New Form I-9
Previous form on an older edition, within 3 yearsSupplement B block on the current edition, kept with the old form
Original Form I-9 cannot be foundNew Form I-9 (you cannot update a form you do not have)
Temp still employed by you between assignmentsNot a rehire, no new Form I-9 needed

Hypothetical example

Imagine a forklift operator whose Form I-9 was completed on March 2, 2024. Your firm ended their employment in late 2024 and rehires them on October 20, 2026. That is within three years, so a Supplement B block works if they are still authorized to work.

If the same worker came back on March 9, 2027, the three years would have passed. They would need a new Form I-9.

Does a temp moving between assignments count as a rehire?

Not if they stay employed by your staffing firm between assignments, because a new assignment is not a new hire.

The question is whether employment actually ended. The regulation treats some people as "continuing in employment." Examples include approved leave, a temporary layoff for lack of work, and seasonal employment. The worker must have a reasonable expectation of returning.

The factors listed in 8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(viii) include:

  • whether the worker was employed on a regular and substantial basis
  • the employer's history of recalling absent workers
  • whether the worker received severance or retirement benefits
  • whether communications suggest they are likely to return

M-274 section 4.0 also lets staffing firms choose the first day of employment. It can be the date the employee is assigned to their first job, or the date they enter the assignment pool.

Write down your firm's own rule for when a temp is treated as separated. Apply it the same way to everyone.

How do you reverify expired employment authorization on rehire?

If a rehired employee's employment authorization has expired, you reverify it in the Supplement B block before they work.

M-274 sets out how this works:

  • The employee may present any document from List A or List C that shows current employment authorization. You cannot tell them which one to bring.
  • Enter the document title, number and expiration date in the block, then sign and date it.
  • Reject a restricted Social Security card and ask for a different List A or List C document.
  • You cannot continue to employ someone who does not provide proof of current employment authorization.

Reverification is never required for U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals. It is also never required when a U.S. passport, passport card, Green Card or List B document expires.

For the full document lists, see our guide to Form I-9 acceptable documents.

What about current employees whose authorization runs out?

The same Supplement B process applies while the temp is still working for you. M-274 section 6.1 says you must reverify no later than the date employment authorization expires. Some extensions apply in certain cases, covered in M-274 section 7.0.

Do you create a new E-Verify case for a rehire?

E-Verify's guidance on rehires gives two options. You can treat every rehire as a new hire, with a new Form I-9 and a new case. Or you can use Supplement B, but complete a new Form I-9 and create a case if the worker never had an E-Verify case, or their last case did not end in "employment authorized".

How long do you keep the Form I-9 for a rehired employee?

Keep a rehire's existing Form I-9 for three years from when it was first completed, or one year after employment ends. Whichever is later applies.

That rule for rehires is in 8 CFR 274a.2(c)(2). The general rule, in M-274 section 10.0, is three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.

Never dispose of a Form I-9 for someone who still works for you. Keep every Supplement B block with the form it belongs to.

How should a staffing firm track I-9 rehires across assignments?

Track four dates on every worker's record, and check them before anyone is re-assigned.

FieldWhy it matters
Date original Form I-9 was completedStarts the three-year rehire window
Date employment endedTells you whether the next assignment is a rehire
Work authorization expiration dateTriggers reverification before it lapses
Form I-9 retention dateTells you when the form can be destroyed

Then use this checklist before a returning temp starts:

  • Confirm whether employment ended or the temp stayed in your pool
  • Find the original Form I-9 and note the date it was completed
  • Count three years from that date and compare with the rehire date
  • Check which Form I-9 edition the old form uses
  • Check whether work authorization has expired
  • Complete a Supplement B block or a new Form I-9 within the M-274 timing
  • Decide whether a new E-Verify case is needed, using E-Verify's rehire guidance
  • Recalculate the retention date and update the record

Keep these fields in your ATS rather than a separate spreadsheet. Then recruiters see the same dates as compliance when they re-book a temp. If you place in light industrial or other high-turnover roles, rehires will be common.

Where Amy fits

The rehire rules are a checklist, but chasing a returning temp for a current document is still slow.

Amy, our AI document agent, chases candidates over WhatsApp or by email from your firm's own domain. When a rehire needs reverification, she can ask the worker for a List A or List C document of their choice. She answers their questions in the same thread. Candidates get no portal and no login.

Documents she accepts are filed to the worker's record in your ATS. Your team still examines documents and completes the Form I-9 as the rules require.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a new Form I-9 when I rehire a former employee?

Not always. If you rehire them within three years of the date their previous Form I-9 was completed, you may complete a Supplement B block instead. After three years, a new Form I-9 is required.

What is the 3-year rule for Form I-9 rehires?

The three years run from the date the original Form I-9 was completed, not from the date the employee left. Within that window you can update the existing form in Supplement B. Outside it, the employee completes a new Form I-9.

What is Supplement B on Form I-9?

Supplement B is the Reverification and Rehire page of the current Form I-9, formerly Section 3. Employers use it to record a rehire date, a name change or reverification of expired employment authorization. Each block is kept with the original Form I-9.

Do I have to reverify a rehired U.S. citizen?

No. Reverification is never required for U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals. For a rehire within three years, you just record the rehire date in Supplement B.

Is a temp starting a new assignment a rehire for Form I-9?

Not if they stayed employed by your staffing firm between assignments. A rehire only happens when employment actually ended. The regulation's continuing employment factors help you decide when it ended.

How long must I keep a rehired employee's Form I-9?

Keep a rehired employee's Form I-9 for three years from when it was first completed, or one year after employment ends. Whichever is later applies. Never destroy the form of someone who still works for you.

Want returning temps cleared before their first shift?

If re-booking temps keeps stalling on missing documents, we can show you how Amy chases them in a normal conversation. Book a call and we'll walk you through it with your own document list.


Please note: this article is general information, not legal advice, and was correct at the time of writing (October 2026). Rules and guidance change, so please check the latest guidance from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) before relying on it.

Written by

Michael